Elections

Durham County Council elections, 2021: Esh and Witton Gilbert

Summary: Elections to Durham County Council in May 2021
Polling date: Thursday 6th May 2021
Division:
Candidates
(by surname):
  • Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER  (Green Party)
  • Bev COULT  (Liberal Democrat)
  • Ryan Lee Pescod DRION  (Independent)
  • Alison Mary HILES  (Labour Party)
  • Alison HIRST  (Conservative Party)
  • David Robert MILNER  (Conservative Party)
  • Arnie SIMPSON  (Liberal Democrat)
  • Ian Edward STONE  (Green Party)
  • Andy WALKER  (Labour Party)

Candidates who have not yet responded are welcome to contact us with their replies to the questions for us to publish.

Questions for Esh and Witton Gilbert division candidates (5 questions)

Jump to question:  1   2   3   4   5 

# Question 1

What experiences do you or your family members have of cycling for either transport or leisure? Bearing in mind that e-bikes can now make County Durham's hills easy, what would you consider to be the main barriers which prevent more people from cycling in your area, and how would you tackle these?

Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER
(Green Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Bev COULT
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ryan Lee Pescod DRION
(Independent)

I was a keen cyclist but not a fit as I used to be. The Lanchester Valley Walk and Cycle Route 14 passes through Esh and Witton Gilbert. This route following the former railway line links many others both at Broompark Picnic Area and Lydgetts Junction in Consett. At Wallnook the cycle route follows Wallnook Lane which leads on to Front Street and the main road to the A691. There is no road crossing here and vehicles approaching from the A691 are at the national speed limit and vehicles heading to the A691 are traveling over the 30MPH limit before reaching the National Speed Limit.. A signalised crossing point was proposed here as part of the outline planning for up to 400 homes but would not have been operational until the 49th was occupied. The reserved matters for 342 homes was refused earlier in 2021. Though the National Speed Limit was to be reduced to 40MPH, the development if given permission would not have completed until 2034. Despite this the route is well used and links to the rest of the cycle network. Though the development of the houses may come back at a later date as part of the County Durham Plan there's no reason why a crossing can't be provided here. However a pegasus crossing would be more appropriate as horse riders also use the route. This was not considered as a suitable location however during the planning process and many of the objections to the development mentioned a Pegasus Crossing.

Alison Mary HILES
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Alison HIRST
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
David Robert MILNER
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Arnie SIMPSON
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ian Edward STONE
(Green Party)

I regularly cycle, both for exercise and as an alternative to car travel, doing perhaps 100 miles in some weeks, and periodically cycle over to the North West. The main problem locally in Durham is the fragmentation of the system and the frequent points at which it is dangerous for the cyclist. For example, the segregation is effective near the Arnison Centre, but what happens at the roundabout? This situation is the same across Durham: you cannot cycle safely anywhere; the lanes stop and start or are non-existent; cars/lorries are unimpeded in terms of speed or giving way at crossing points/where space needs to be shared. What is wrong with the idea of having more 'give way to cyclist' points, with safe margins built in? I believe the council, some years ago, visited Groningen to learn from its system, but I see no evidence that this has led to a proper balance between bikes and cars etc. Until you have viable, safe, segregated lanes and articulation points that are safe for cyclists aged (say) 8 to 80, people will not use their bicycles to an optimal level.

Andy WALKER
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.

# Question 2

Schools in County Durham have bike shelters but they are often empty. Children who might like to cycle are often driven to school because parents don't consider our streets safe enough for children to walk or cycle. What are your views about cycling as a travel option for children? What practical changes would you like to see in your area to enable children to cycle?

Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER
(Green Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Bev COULT
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ryan Lee Pescod DRION
(Independent)

Many of the schools in the area attract pupils from other villages and other areas. Esh has both a Church of England and Catholic Primary School and getting too and from school by cycling would be impractical. Some parents do walk between Langley Park and Esh, but most drive. Langley Park and Witton Gilbert do have a lot of through traffic and often queuing traffic leading to rat running down back streets. Though I would agree that cycling has benefits, I can understand the hesitation of parents allowing their children to reach school this way. Speeding in all villages is a concern and all candidates have expressed this in their election flyers. In Langley Park, new estates built in the last 20 years would have enabled walking and cycling without the need to travel along Low Moor Road but land was allowed to be purchased to expand gardens which resulted in these links between estates closed. Hospital Road though can still be accessed from Maplewood Court there is now no link to Herrington Close which also links to Middridge Road. Schools also have breakfast clubs and after school activities which are there for parents who need to drop off their children early to get to work or pick up later. This means parents will drive to school to and from work.

Alison Mary HILES
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Alison HIRST
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
David Robert MILNER
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Arnie SIMPSON
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ian Edward STONE
(Green Party)

Cycling should be encouraged for school-children. At the moment, sending a child off on a bike in the morning must (or would) cause many parents great anxiety, for the reasons listed in answer 1. Given physical limitations on sharing space, consideration should perhaps be given to modifying footpath use, where that is feasible. Other alternatives might be group cycling to school, organised in a similar way to the escorted walk schemes operating in some places, perhaps with strict speed and overtaking rules for traffic applied for short periods of the day. Businesses might be engaged in sponsoring routes (attracted by advertising and CSR). The best thing to do would be to improve the system for all cyclists, so school journeys are more convenient and safer.

Andy WALKER
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.

# Question 3

The surge in cycling during the Covid 19 lockdowns showed how quieter and safer conditions encourage people to cycle. Cycling can help address many issues:

* the climate emergency, if people cycle instead of making shorter journeys by car
* social inclusion, because cycling is affordable and enables those on low incomes to access employment and other opportunities
* the health crisis, as exercise incorporated into journeys is very effective

How big a role do you think cycling can play in tackling these urgent issues? How can Durham County Council increase investment in cycling and quickly deliver safe, complete cycle routes to key destinations?

Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER
(Green Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Bev COULT
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ryan Lee Pescod DRION
(Independent)

Durham County Council have already put measure in place such as on Rotary Way and along Pity Me and Framwellgate Front Street. I can count on one hand the number of times I have seen these in use by cyclists. There is already a number of shared foot / cycle routes though often cyclists don't use these and instead continue to the use the road. Roads had become quieter with most who could working from home. The County Durham Plan though adopted is missing two vital relief roads that would have enabled Durham County Council to divert the A690 and A691 out of the city centre and enabling better management of the main roads. This could have been a combination of bus and cycle lanes. A additional Park and Ride at Stonebridge would have been close to Broom Park Picnic Area and where three cycling and walking routes converge. Business and for that matter customers using these in the city centre have no safe and secure place for their bikes. Theft and often vandalism puts people off using this method of transport. What is also to be considered is that The Passport Office, National Savings and soon to be finished new County Hall do have secure cycling but maybe only used by a small number of people who live close by.

Alison Mary HILES
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Alison HIRST
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
David Robert MILNER
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Arnie SIMPSON
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ian Edward STONE
(Green Party)

There is no alternative here: authorities have to move away from giving priority to cars etc. We need to move much further in prioritising public transport, walking and cycling over cars, which will itself help in re-setting the balance, by encouraging people at the margin to switch away from cars. Car parking provision (and charges) in the centre, e-bike stations using hire models and priority access arrangements are all examples of action to achieve this, and constructive collaboration will be important to the process. The Netherlands is a model for such interaction with local businesses - why aren't we learning from best practice?

Andy WALKER
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.

# Question 4

Getting from Langley Park to the cycle path along the A691 to Witton Gilbert and Durham City involves a few challenges: crossing the main road to Wallnook Lane, negotiating the barriers at Wallnook Bridge, crossing the main road at the roundabout on the A691, and the various junctions from there to Durham. What measures would you like to see implemented to improve the safety of this route and make cycling possible for more of the community?

Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER
(Green Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Bev COULT
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ryan Lee Pescod DRION
(Independent)

For a time, Wallnook Bridge was completely closed. Kaysburn Roundabout can be difficult to negotiate. From here Witton Gilbert Roundabout, then the junction which continues to be a rat run is unsafe if drivers decide last minute to turn right sometimes without indicating they are going to do so. The A691 can be an up hill struggle and then need to get over Trouts Lane. Sniperley Park and Ride Is too small and I believe to be expanded in the future. Perhaps the solution here would be increased parking for cycles and as an incentive these users could perhaps benefit from a reduction of the fare. The shared foot / cycle path is not that wide and again often cyclists prefer to use the road. There is no difference between using the A691 compared to the Lanchester Valley Walk to reach Durham for example and both exactly 4.7 miles and only 1 minute slower using the mainly traffic free route.

Alison Mary HILES
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Alison HIRST
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
David Robert MILNER
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Arnie SIMPSON
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ian Edward STONE
(Green Party)

For these routes, and all routes across the city, the journey from the perspective of the cyclist needs to be fully documented in terms of quality of surface, safety, waiting/delays, clarity of route signage etc., and a real collaborative effort made to address the issues that disrupt/slow the bike journey or make it potentially dangerous. It is time, also, that we had a real public campaign to show that the community is on the side of those who are young, do not possess a vehicle, or are cycling for fitness or pleasure. Rules and conventions need to be changed. A bold approach is called for, with the ambition to create a genuine cycling culture in Durham, and make it an example of practice that others want to copy.

Andy WALKER
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.

# Question 5

The housing development at Sniperley Park is likely to come forward as a planning application soon. What sustainable transport improvements would you like to see provided in order to minimise the impact on the road network of this large site? Will you secure good-quality cycling routes connecting to Framwellgate Moor and Durham city centre for access to employment, schools and shops, as envisaged in the Durham City Sustainable Transport Delivery Plan?

Ruth Clementine BLANCHFLOWER
(Green Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Bev COULT
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ryan Lee Pescod DRION
(Independent)

There are already cycle routes conecting Framwellgate Moor to Durham City, two mainly off road and one as a shared footway / cycle path. As above the expansion of the Park and Ride site at Sniperley would be better suitable if linked to this development either with more cycle parking or encouraging people living there who may work in the city centre to walk and use the bus service. However many of the proposed site for housing including Sniperley Park had no guarantee that these homes would be lived in by people working in the city centre. Aykley Heads for example has a multistorey car park included in the long term plan. Electric buses used instead of diesel or hybrid types would make this environmentally friendly. Currently the buses serving this site also serve the Park and Ride at Belmont. Incidents on the A1(M) leading to the closure result in traffic diverted through the city centre and delays to all bus services. It would be far better to have the Park and Ride buses go direct from these sites and return back to the same site. Though this may require additional buses added to the fleet, this also creates an opportunity for employment of more drivers. Sniperley Park however can be easily connected to the already established cycling and walking routes through Framwellgate Moor, Aykley Heads and in to the city centre. This mostly follows former wagon ways crossing Framwellgate Moor Front Street and down to Old Pit Lane. Though this route would be 2.7 miles and take around 14 minutes to cycle, the more direct routes using the main roads are between 2.2 and 2.3 miles and taking between 11 and 12 minutes.

Alison Mary HILES
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Alison HIRST
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
David Robert MILNER
(Conservative Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Arnie SIMPSON
(Liberal Democrat)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.
Ian Edward STONE
(Green Party)

In ALL developments considered by planning authorities, cycle routes - segregated, safe and connecting the place to shops , facilities etc. - should be enforced as compulsory requirements in the application. These should be integrated with all aspects of of the infrastructure, not added as an afterthought. Such routes should be allocated a share of the investment that demonstrates a priority is being given to cycling and cyclists (and others also using the routes, such as walkers and runners).

Andy WALKER
(Labour Party)
The candidate has not responded to the survey.

SPACE for Durham is a non-partisan body. All candidates are given an equal opportunity to submit their views. Information published by SPACE for Durham, c/o 35 Archery Rise, Durham, DH1 4LA.